PISA 2025 · Education strategy
Spain and Singapore in PISA 2025: building a measurable education reputation
Compare Spain and Singapore through PISA results, documented practices and policy choices. Download the tables and explore an agenda with owners and indicators for learning, equity and trust.
- Source published
- Effective date or period
- 2025 assessment; editorial proposals for 2026–2030, not binding rules
- Article on this portal
OECD results · Independent analysis and proposals

01 · Measured results
Spain 🇪🇸 · Singapore 🇸🇬
PISA 2025 means. Singapore is the highest-scoring national reference across the three core subjects; B-S-J-Z represents four Chinese territories. Each scale is interpreted separately.
| Subject | Spain | Singapore | OECD mean | Singapore − Spain |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Science | 477 | 560 | 482 | +83 |
| Reading | 451 | 535 | 461 | +84 |
| Mathematics | 457 | 563 | 463 | +106 |
| Computational problem solving | 499 | 563 | 500 | +64 |
On narrow screens, swipe the table to see every column.
These are not percentages, years behind or a composite score. Sorting by gap is arithmetic and does not equate scale difficulty. Consult OECD confidence intervals and sampling cautions; exclusions in Spain require attention.
02 · A comparison for decisions
What to adapt. How to evaluate it.
Filter by area or search a topic. The country columns present documented facts; the final column proposes actions for Spain. These are improvement hypotheses requiring evaluation, not causal effects established by PISA.
8 / 8 criteria
| Criterion and sources | Singapore · Documented | Spain · Documented | Proposal for Spain |
|---|---|---|---|
| Teaching and assessmentUnderstand and solve | The mathematics framework centres on problem solving, combining concepts, skills, processes, metacognition and attitudes. | The lower-secondary curriculum also includes problem solving and reasoning. The legal text does not establish how every classroom implements it. | Editorial proposal Pilot sequences connecting concrete, visual and symbolic representations, teacher explanation, practice and unfamiliar problems. Ask pupils to justify their strategy.
|
| Teaching and assessmentScience through evidence | The science syllabus connects ideas, practices and values, including inquiry questions and evaluation of experimental results. | Lower-secondary minimum requirements include scientific projects, data interpretation and argumentation. | Editorial proposal Include a guided investigation in each unit: form a hypothesis, measure, discuss limitations and explain what evidence would change the conclusion.
|
| Teaching and assessmentAssess to provide support | The mathematics syllabus combines formative and summative assessment and uses the information to adjust teaching. | Article 15 of Royal Decree 217/2022 requires continuous, formative, integrated assessment and support when difficulties emerge. | Editorial proposal Agree short ungraded diagnostics, useful feedback and an intervention with an owner and review date. Avoid adding tests without subsequent support.
|
| Teachers and school climateConditions for teaching | 37% of pupils attend schools whose principals report that staff shortages hinder teaching, at least to some extent. | The equivalent share is 49%. These are pupil-weighted principal reports, not counts of vacant posts. | Editorial proposal Cover critical absences, protect shared planning time and connect professional development with classroom observation and mentoring.
|
| Teachers and school climateAttention and school climate | 31% report noise or disorder in most or all science lessons; 29% report classmates’ digital distraction. | The shares are 39% and 29%. Responses describe perceived experiences and may vary across cultures. | Editorial proposal Establish attention routines, sustained reading and purposeful screen use. For AI-supported tasks, require sources, personal explanation and error checking.
|
| Teachers and school climatePreserve strengths | In the attached tables: group 3 for belonging and group 7 for self-reported perseverance. | Spain is in groups 10 and 9 respectively. These are relative country groups, not marks out of ten or pupil percentages. | Editorial proposal Raise academic expectations while preserving inclusion, belonging and family participation. Do not use country groupings to diagnose an individual.
|
| Coordination and equityCoherence across levels | Ministry syllabuses set out common learning frameworks and progressions. | The Education Act distributes responsibilities and provides for territorial cooperation: a common framework with regional and school-level development. | Editorial proposal Agree a small set of shared goals, compatible indicators and multi-year funding. Retain linguistic and regional adaptation and evaluate delivery.
|
| Coordination and equityExcellence with equity | A high mean does not establish which funding arrangement or provider causes it. PISA does not randomly assign pupils to school models. | Public, state-subsidised private and independent schools operate under different rules; comparisons need intake context and full costs. | Editorial proposal Prioritise new public investment where capacity and support are insufficient. Audit funding agreements and alternatives, including transition costs; preserve private autonomy within legal safeguards.
|
Teaching and assessment
Understand and solve
Singapore · Documented
The mathematics framework centres on problem solving, combining concepts, skills, processes, metacognition and attitudes.
Spain · Documented
The lower-secondary curriculum also includes problem solving and reasoning. The legal text does not establish how every classroom implements it.
Pilot sequences connecting concrete, visual and symbolic representations, teacher explanation, practice and unfamiliar problems. Ask pupils to justify their strategy.
- Proposed owner
- Heads of studies and subject teams
- First review
- 3 months
- What to measure
- Progress on transfer problems using a common rubric; review after 8 and 12 weeks.
Teaching and assessment
Science through evidence
Singapore · Documented
The science syllabus connects ideas, practices and values, including inquiry questions and evaluation of experimental results.
Spain · Documented
Lower-secondary minimum requirements include scientific projects, data interpretation and argumentation.
Include a guided investigation in each unit: form a hypothesis, measure, discuss limitations and explain what evidence would change the conclusion.
- Proposed owner
- Science departments
- First review
- 3 months
- What to measure
- Work samples assessed jointly by two teachers; quality of explanation rather than the number of experiments.
Teaching and assessment
Assess to provide support
Singapore · Documented
The mathematics syllabus combines formative and summative assessment and uses the information to adjust teaching.
Spain · Documented
Article 15 of Royal Decree 217/2022 requires continuous, formative, integrated assessment and support when difficulties emerge.
Agree short ungraded diagnostics, useful feedback and an intervention with an owner and review date. Avoid adding tests without subsequent support.
- Proposed owner
- Teaching and guidance teams
- First review
- 3 months
- What to measure
- Time from detection to support; pupils improving on an equivalent follow-up task.
Teachers and school climate
Conditions for teaching
Singapore · Documented
37% of pupils attend schools whose principals report that staff shortages hinder teaching, at least to some extent.
Spain · Documented
The equivalent share is 49%. These are pupil-weighted principal reports, not counts of vacant posts.
Cover critical absences, protect shared planning time and connect professional development with classroom observation and mentoring.
- Proposed owner
- Regional authorities, providers and school leaders
- First review
- 12 months
- What to measure
- Teaching days without cover and the share of teams with mentoring and protected time.
Teachers and school climate
Attention and school climate
Singapore · Documented
31% report noise or disorder in most or all science lessons; 29% report classmates’ digital distraction.
Spain · Documented
The shares are 39% and 29%. Responses describe perceived experiences and may vary across cultures.
Establish attention routines, sustained reading and purposeful screen use. For AI-supported tasks, require sources, personal explanation and error checking.
- Proposed owner
- School leadership and safeguarding coordinator
- First review
- 3 months
- What to measure
- Effective lesson time, text comprehension and anonymous perceptions of safety; also check unintended effects.
Teachers and school climate
Preserve strengths
Singapore · Documented
In the attached tables: group 3 for belonging and group 7 for self-reported perseverance.
Spain · Documented
Spain is in groups 10 and 9 respectively. These are relative country groups, not marks out of ten or pupil percentages.
Raise academic expectations while preserving inclusion, belonging and family participation. Do not use country groupings to diagnose an individual.
- Proposed owner
- Pastoral teams and the school community
- First review
- 3 months
- What to measure
- Track learning and wellbeing separately; review absence and climate alongside academic progress.
Coordination and equity
Coherence across levels
Singapore · Documented
Ministry syllabuses set out common learning frameworks and progressions.
Spain · Documented
The Education Act distributes responsibilities and provides for territorial cooperation: a common framework with regional and school-level development.
Agree a small set of shared goals, compatible indicators and multi-year funding. Retain linguistic and regional adaptation and evaluate delivery.
- Proposed owner
- Ministry and regional education conference
- First review
- 12 months
- What to measure
- A public agreement, budget and results dashboard within twelve months; monitoring by need and territory.
Coordination and equity
Excellence with equity
Singapore · Documented
A high mean does not establish which funding arrangement or provider causes it. PISA does not randomly assign pupils to school models.
Spain · Documented
Public, state-subsidised private and independent schools operate under different rules; comparisons need intake context and full costs.
Prioritise new public investment where capacity and support are insufficient. Audit funding agreements and alternatives, including transition costs; preserve private autonomy within legal safeguards.
- Proposed owner
- Authorities, independent evaluators and providers
- First review
- 12 months
- What to measure
- Full cost per needs-weighted pupil, effective access, progress and segregation. Do not rank schools by raw means.
Reading attitudes: the PDF’s 1–10 groups place country/economy means into relative groups (1: lowest 10%; 10: highest 10%). They do not measure causality, and cultural differences may affect responses. Missing data are not filled in.
Our interpretation
Why it matters
A strong education reputation grows when pupils can pursue ambitious learning and obtain support wherever they live. Singapore offers a demanding reference point; Spain’s task is to turn comparison into better opportunities rather than promises about league-table positions.
Editorial recommendation
What to do
I propose a 2026–2030 agenda agreed by the Ministry and autonomous communities: shared goals, early support, teacher development and public evaluation of resources. The comparison separates documented practices and measured outcomes from recommendations that still require testing.
Verified facts
Why Singapore, and what does ‘best country’ mean?
Among participants reporting national results, Singapore has the highest means in science, reading and mathematics in the attached tables. That explicit criterion determines this comparison; it does not establish the best system on every dimension or invent a composite of three separate scales.
B-S-J-Z outperforms Singapore in science and mathematics but represents Beijing, Shanghai, Jiangsu and Zhejiang, rather than China as a whole. Singapore also leads the reading table including economies and territories. Point rankings do not incorporate uncertainty intervals.
Attached comparative tables · pp. 1, 3 and 4OECD · Reader’s Guide and territorial coverage
Editorial analysis
What the evidence can establish
Spain scores 477 in science against Singapore’s 560; 451 against 535 in reading; and 457 against 563 in mathematics. The arithmetic differences are 83, 84 and 106 points. They are neither percentage shortfalls nor years of schooling lost by individual pupils. Computational problem solving is shown separately and is not added to the other scales.
PISA studies a sample of 15-year-olds. It is not an experiment isolating the effect of a teaching method, a law or decentralisation. Comparing a city-state with Spain requires attention to population, social context, language, selection and institutional arrangements.
The OECD accepts Spain’s national comparison but flags exclusions of 7.9% and potential upward bias; it does not report Catalonia separately. Nor does it describe Spain’s science change since 2022 as statistically significant. These limitations matter for evaluation without invalidating the exercise.
OECD · Spain country note and data qualityOECD · Singapore country note
Editorial analysis
From an imported method to everyday teaching
Singapore’s documentation combines understanding, practice, inquiry and assessment. Spanish rules already include competency goals and formative assessment. The editorial question is which support, professional time and materials turn those intentions into observable learning.
The cited syllabuses document practices; they do not reconstruct every lesson experienced by the PISA cohort. In particular, the October 2025 mathematics revision cannot establish what caused the results of pupils tested that year.
As a first intervention, I propose sustained reading with discussion of evidence, unfamiliar mathematical problems and guided scientific investigation. Professional development should support an actual teaching sequence and review pupils’ work. A course catalogue or technology purchase alone cannot demonstrate improvement.
Editorial recommendation
Marca España 🇪🇸: four verifiable commitments
‘Marca España in education’ here means an editorial proposal for public trust, not an approved government programme. Reputation should follow the opportunities the system guarantees and the results it can evidence. I propose negotiating these goals for 2030 and assessing them with comparable data.
- Basic learning: reduce the share below Level 2 in each core subject by at least five percentage points from 2025, checked against the next available comparable international assessment. Spain’s reference shares are 33% in mathematics, 32% in reading and 24% in science, calculated from rounded OECD country-note percentages. This is a proposed target, not a forecast.
- Accessible excellence: increase the share able to tackle complex tasks without worsening outcomes for pupils who struggle. Publish both ends of the distribution alongside means and confidence intervals, rather than making a world ranking the sole objective.
- Territorial equity: within twelve months, agree a transparent formula for support based on educational and social need, with multi-year commitments. Publish access to support and progress by territory while protecting small groups and avoiding political blame based on raw differences.
- Professional trust: before the end of 2027, publish monitoring of staff cover, time for applied development and access to guidance. Inspection should examine delivery and evidence of improvement alongside documentary compliance, within its legal remit.
OECD · Proficiency levels in SpainBOE · Cooperation and equity in the Education Act
Editorial recommendation
Ministry and regions: shared goals and delivery capacity
I invite the Ministry to make the next regional education conference an agreement on delivery: which learning outcomes should improve, who funds the work, what each territory receives and how results will be assessed. Regional responsibilities have a legal basis; simply attributing PISA declines to them is not causal analysis.
The fragmentation worth investigating concerns uneven support, incompatible data, discontinuous budgets and differing capacity to implement measures. I propose identifying these gaps through common indicators and needs-based transfers, respecting co-official languages and regional adaptation.
First 90 days: agree baselines, owners, data safeguards and a limited portfolio of interventions. Months 4–12: run diverse pilots, with comparison groups where feasible, full costs and independent evaluation. Subsequently expand what works, correct what fails and publish negative findings too.
Editorial recommendation
Public, subsidised and independent schools: what to fund and why
Comparison with Singapore does not show that transferring all funding for state-subsidised private schools to public provision would have improved PISA. That counterfactual requires estimates of places, buildings, staffing, transport, inclusion and transition, and comparison of progress among similar pupils rather than average spending per place alone.
My position is to prioritise additional investment in public provision where needs remain unmet and compare alternatives through independent evaluation. For existing funding agreements, I propose reviewing full costs, effective free access, admissions and support for additional needs. Changes must respect the legal framework, planning and families’ educational continuity.
Independent private schools should develop their projects autonomously with their own funding, within applicable authorisation, qualification, pupil-rights and educational requirements. A credible education reputation needs good outcomes and transparency across all networks; it cannot attribute success to ownership without considering intake.
BOE · Education Act: admissions, free access and funding agreementsBOE · Independent-school autonomy
Editorial recommendation
One useful decision for the next meeting
Each school leader can select one comparison row, assign an owner and bring a sample of pupils’ work to the next teaching meeting. After twelve weeks, the team should be able to explain what changed in teaching, which pupils improved and who still needs support.
That is the purpose of this proposal: a reputation for Spanish education built on explainable practices, verifiable opportunities and sustained improvement. Share the analysis or contribute a documented school experience in the comments.
Earlier analysis: PISA and Spain’s action planGuide to Spain’s education system
Primary source and reading standard
OECD · PISA 2025, Volume ICheck the original document and its date before acting. The portal’s proposals are labelled as editorial recommendations and do not replace applicable rules.
Disclosure: Luis Manuel Tolmos has a professional connection with Brains International Schools, described in his profile. This analysis is independent.
Continue the conversation
Share a reflection, question or experience related to this conversation.
Comments are reviewed before publication and shared across the Spanish and English editions. Do not include children’s personal data, confidential information, personal attacks or advertising.
Loading discussion…