PISA 2025 · Spain
PISA 2025: what Spain should do and where each school can start
PISA 2025: learning, regional coordination and the funding of public, state-funded private and independent schools. A twelve-month Ministry agenda and a 90-day school plan, with official sources and clearly labelled editorial proposals.
- Source published
- Effective date or period
- 2025 assessment · No legal commencement date
- Article on this portal
Official results · Editorial analysis and recommendations

Our interpretation
Why it matters
For school leaders, the value lies in asking better questions about their pupils and checking which support works. An international comparison becomes useful when it leads to objectives, named responsibilities and evidence of progress.
Editorial recommendation
What to do
Choose two learning priorities, establish a baseline and agree a termly review. This article's plan is an editorial proposal, not a Ministry instruction or a specific OECD recommendation to Spain.
Verified facts
What Spain’s results show
- Compared with 2022, mathematics and reading declined; science was broadly stable. All three averages were below the OECD mean.
- At least Level 2: mathematics 67%, reading 68%, science 76%. Mathematics Levels 5–6: 4%, versus 8% across the OECD.
- Exclusions reached 7.9%. The OECD retains national comparability but flags possible upward bias; Catalonia is not reported separately. Avoid incomplete regional rankings.
Context and timetable
Available now, and still to come
The main assessment took place in spring 2025. INEE dates the core results and digital preview to 8 September 2026; foreign-language results are scheduled for 6 April 2027, with the full digital report in May 2027. Those findings should not be anticipated.
Ministry of Education · INEE: PISA 2025 timetable and materials
Editorial analysis
Our interpretation: intervene and check learning
We propose addressing both foundational gaps and deeper reasoning. A national mean cannot diagnose an individual pupil or attribute a school’s results to one teaching method. Before transferring a conclusion to Spain, a region or a school network, check the population, uncertainty and context.
The OECD highlights curriculum depth, teacher support, family engagement and targeted help. It calls for purposeful technology and AI use: observed associations with attainment do not establish causation. Our recommendation is to assess what pupils can explain and solve, including without digital assistance.
Editorial recommendation
Actions we propose for Spain
- Ministry and autonomous communities: agree measurable priorities in reading, mathematical and scientific reasoning; explain how support is allocated and evaluate outcomes by social context, using aggregate data and protecting privacy.
- Authorities and school owners: protect time for coordination and teacher development linked to actual classroom tasks. Before scaling a programme, check implementation, cost, participation and pupil progress.
- Universities and initial teacher education: connect school placements, subject teaching and assessment. Work with schools to evaluate interventions without treating a national correlation as a universal recipe.
Editorial analysis
To the Ministry: examine fragmentation without simplifying its causes
We invite the Ministry and regional education departments to evaluate territorial coordination publicly: which decisions are duplicated, which policies change without evaluation, and where a pupil receives less support because of their postcode. This is an editorial proposal. PISA describes outcomes and associations; it does not isolate the causal effect of devolved powers or a political party.
Autonomous communities exercise statutory powers, rather than a merely revocable administrative delegation. The Education Act provides for common objectives and territorial cooperation. We propose using those instruments for shared learning guarantees, comparable indicators and room for regional adaptation.
The hypothesis to test is whether political discontinuity, bureaucracy and incompatible funding or assessment criteria impede the transfer of effective interventions between regions. The benefits of locally adapted provision also need examination. Centralisation does not guarantee implementation quality; decentralisation does not guarantee equity.
BOE · Education Act, Articles 6 bis and 7–9: responsibilities and cooperation
Editorial analysis
Regional resources: compare need and actual expenditure
The statistical starting point is public expenditure by administration and activity. The cited Ministry series for 2023 is retrospective, not a measure of the budget available in 2026. We provide neither a regional league table nor a savings estimate here: those would require comparable years, educational stages and accounting categories.
We propose comparing expenditure per equivalent pupil, adjusting for deprivation, additional support needs, rural dispersion, island geography, staffing costs and the mix of educational stages. GDP shares, announced budgets and a department’s total spending do not by themselves measure the resources reaching classrooms.
Fiscal capacity, political priorities and implementation efficiency are different explanations and should be examined separately. The Ministry should report the support actually received by disadvantaged pupils, unfilled teaching posts, workforce stability and progress from a common baseline. Additional funding is a resource decision; improved learning also requires checking how it is used.
Ministry · Public expenditure on education, 2023: final results
Editorial analysis
State-funded private and independent schools: distinguish the regimes
Concertados are privately owned schools receiving public funding for contracted provision. The Education Act requires tuition-free provision in those stages, admission rules and obligations linked to the funding agreement. Public funding entails accountability; it does not make the entire school publicly owned.
We propose examining funding adequacy, tuition-free access, actual admissions and enrolment of pupils with additional needs together. If a funding allowance fails to cover required provision, this should be demonstrated through verifiable costs. Charges incompatible with tuition-free access should be investigated and remedied. We do not allege wrongdoing across an entire sector.
The analysis should include families unable to afford additional services, late-arriving pupils and public schools maintaining capacity in areas less attractive to other providers. Raw attainment averages or a comparison limited to the subsidy per place can conceal these differences.
BOE · Education Act: admissions, free provision and funding agreements, Articles 84, 88 and 116–117
Editorial recommendation
What if those funds had strengthened public schools instead?
This is a relevant counterfactual, not a finding established by PISA. We support evaluating a policy prioritising new public places where needed and avoiding publicly funded extra capacity without a demonstrated social purpose. Before concluding that all funding for concertados would have improved public schools, calculate the service the public sector would need to absorb.
A substitution scenario must estimate how many families would move to public schools, existing spare capacity, and additional land, buildings, equipment, staffing, transport and specialist support. A discontinued transfer is not automatically a net saving; nor does today’s average public-school cost equal the marginal cost of enrolling one additional pupil.
We propose comparing three scenarios: retaining funding agreements with stronger safeguards; allocating future increases to strengthened public provision; and gradually replacing contracted places at expiry where legally feasible and sufficient alternative capacity exists. Compare ten-year costs, accessibility, segregation, learning and effects on families and employment.
Our editorial recommendation is stable objectives and resources for public schools, with an evaluation of the actual purpose of each funding agreement. A transition must preserve a free alternative for pupils and respect existing commitments. A stronger public network alongside independent private schools merits comparative study, not a promise of savings or a premature causal conclusion.
Editorial analysis
Independent schools: autonomy with common safeguards
The Right to Education Act grants non-contracted private schools autonomy over their educational project, organisation and economic arrangements within the legal framework. Operating without public funding agreements does not remove authorisation, teacher qualification, child protection or applicable curriculum and qualification requirements.
We propose reviewing administrative burdens that duplicate checks or prescribe processes without demonstrated value, while retaining inspection and safeguards. Independent schools should have room to innovate and responsibility for outcomes; public schools need management autonomy backed by real capacity and support. Educational freedom should coexist with accurate information for families and pupil protection.
Disclosure: my professional connection with Brains International Schools may be relevant when assessing this position. This is an editorial proposal, not an OECD finding or an endorsement of a particular school network.
BOE · Right to Education Act, Articles 23 and 25: authorisation and autonomy
Editorial recommendation
A proposed Ministry agenda: twelve months, named responsibilities and evaluation
This timetable is a public invitation to analysis and debate. It does not imply that the Ministry has received, endorsed or adopted the proposal.
- First 90 days · Ministry, INEE and regional departments: agree a common diagnostic template by region and social context, documenting PISA exclusions and sampling limitations. Deliverable: a public comparison protocol without rankings that conceal uncertainty.
- Months 1–3 · Sectoral Conference: agree minimum reading and mathematics support, with needs-based criteria, responsibilities and a timetable. Publish the allocation formula and explain exceptions; administrative capacity to apply for funds should not replace educational need.
- Months 3–6 · Regional departments and financial controllers: map costs and occupancy of public and contracted places, charges, support needs and actual spending. Deliverable: comparable aggregate data and an assessment of funding adequacy and compliance.
- Months 3–9 · Regional departments and school leaders: trial intensive support, staffing stability and removal of paperwork without teaching value. Measure participation, support intensity, learning and cost. Use comparable schools and independent evaluation before expanding programmes.
- Months 6–12 · Ministry and competent authorities: publish the three funding and provision scenarios described above, including full costs, timelines and demand sensitivity. Invite scrutiny from families, teachers and all school sectors.
- At year end · Publish outcomes and deviations; retain interventions that work and revise those that do not. Set numerical targets from the baseline; no immediate PISA improvement is promised as an effect of these measures.
Editorial recommendation
A 90-day plan for school leaders and heads of studies
Suggested indicators: progress against a shared rubric, attendance at support and the proportion of pupils explaining their reasoning independently. Set targets after establishing the baseline; these internal measures are not equivalent to PISA scores.
- Days 1–30 · Diagnose. Agree two specific needs with each department; collect baseline reading and problem-solving tasks. Owner: head of studies. Output: a one-page statement of objectives and assessment criteria.
- Days 31–60 · Intervene. Schedule short, frequent support, explicit explanation of strategies and extension tasks. Owners: coordinators and teachers. Record participation and samples of work, avoiding paperwork without a teaching purpose.
- Days 61–90 · Review. Repeat comparable tasks, examine progress and actual access to support; agree what to retain, adjust or stop. Owner: leadership team. Share aggregate outcomes and next steps with staff and families.
Editorial recommendation
Independent schools and families: useful questions
For independent schools, we propose the same evidence standard: show progress and concrete support, explain pupil context and avoid presenting an unadjusted difference as proof that one model is superior. A national result does not certify any individual school’s quality.
Families can ask how the school identifies difficulties, who coordinates support and when it is reviewed. At home, we suggest shared reading, conversations about sources and everyday problems that require explaining a decision; schools should adapt these suggestions to the pupil’s age and needs.
Primary source and reading standard
OECD · Spain country note, PISA 2025Check the original document and its date before acting. The portal’s proposals are labelled as editorial recommendations and do not replace applicable rules.
Disclosure: Luis Manuel Tolmos has a professional connection with Brains International Schools, described in his profile. This analysis is independent.
Continue the conversation
Share a reflection, question or experience related to this conversation.
Comments are reviewed before publication and shared across the Spanish and English editions. Do not include children’s personal data, confidential information, personal attacks or advertising.
Loading discussion…